Klingon Imperial Forums
Welcome,
Guest
. Please
login
or
register
.
Did you miss your
activation email?
05 24, 2012, 10:59: PM
1 Hour
1 Day
1 Week
1 Month
Forever
Login with username, password and session length
Search:
Advanced search
Thu 28Aug2008 22:30 PDT:
Guest access restored.
11538
Posts in
1551
Topics by
820
Members
Latest Member:
sarakkatz
Klingon Imperial Forums
General Discussions
General Discussions
Multi Letter Abbreviations in Klingon Ship Names
« previous
next »
Pages:
[
1
]
Author
Topic: Multi Letter Abbreviations in Klingon Ship Names (Read 3809 times)
qoSagh
Warrior Bard of the Ontological
Thought Master
Offline
Posts: 1032
Multi Letter Abbreviations in Klingon Ship Names
«
on:
08 27, 2007, 08:02: AM »
While reading another topic, there were many points brought up about Klingon ship names. This got me to thinking. For the most part, what we have to work with starts with I.K.V. for Imperial Klingon Vessel. This comes from FASA which developed it for the Role Playing Game, and I believe was used in other games also. Just a quick look at the ongoing debate on military ranks and one can see that for the ease of game mechanics much was done to make the Empire and the Federation more or less equal.
So at the risk of alienating all of Klindom, I put forward this theory, that Klingons would not actually use such abbreviations. Be they I.K.V., I.K.C., K.S.S., K.P.V., whatever. This would be seen as redundant to most Klingons.
The word Imperial is the first redundancy, as there is no Klingon Democracy or Republic (the Imperial Klingon States notwithstanding) to be confused with. The word Klingon should be self evident first by appearance (I remember when the Romulans used a few D7's) second by who you are dealing with. When one sees a Klingon on the viewscreen, they are dealing with a Klingon. The Word Vessel is self explanatory.
I believe Klingons would simply address their ship by name and take it as a given that whoever they were dealing with would know it was a ship.
The only monkey wrench that I see is that I seem to remember somewhere (probably FASA) saying that Klingon ships are not named when they are launched, but named by their Captain after the ship has done something notable and earned the right to a name. So there might be an interaction with the Captain of an unnamed ship. In such cases, I would think just the rank and name of the Captain would be sufficient.
[Edit -- modified thread title for the benefit of spiderbots]
«
Last Edit: 08 27, 2007, 09:45: PM by Kesvirit
»
Logged
qoSagh qlIStIy
meycha of the qaptaQ
www.qaptaQ.org
Prothonotary of the Desert Rite
"I would kill the children of a thousand planets, just to see you smile."
Qunchuy
Discoursing Diplomat
Online
Posts: 279
Re: Multi Letter Abbreviations in Klingon Ship Names
«
Reply #1 on:
08 27, 2007, 06:43: PM »
Quote from: qoSagh on 08 27, 2007, 08:02: AM
I believe Klingons would simply address their ship by name and take it as a given that whoever they were dealing with would know it was a ship.
John Ford agreed with you. ""I am Koth, Koth of the Vengeance." It's his vision of Klindom that informs the beliefs of many fans.
On-screen canon is inconsistent. It tends to use the IKS (Imperial Klingon Ship) or, less frequently, IKC (Imperial Klingon Cruiser) prefix, as in the Vor'cha-class IKS Qu'Vat (TNG "Aquiel") and IKC BortaS (TNG "Redemption"). Occasionally no prefix is used, e.g. Vornak (DS9 "Sons and Daughters").
«
Last Edit: 08 27, 2007, 09:45: PM by Kesvirit
»
Logged
Klythe
ngem Sargh lIghwI' pagh cha'
Administrator
Thought Master
Offline
Posts: 1019
When a show of teeth doesn't work, bite deeply.
Re: Multi Letter Abbreviations in Klingon Ship Names
«
Reply #2 on:
08 29, 2007, 01:09: AM »
One thing I think is consistant. The only ones who use 'header' abbreviations are Starfleet officers. Klingons, so far as I've seen, only refer to their ships as "my (type-of-ship)" or by the name with nothing more than the word 'the' infront of the ship name. "the
pagh
", "the
bortaS
"
Logged
Kehlan
Word Warrior
Online
Posts: 499
Re: Multi Letter Abbreviations in Klingon Ship Names
«
Reply #3 on:
08 29, 2007, 03:32: AM »
I've never heard that about ships being unnamed uintil they prove themselves - and I know novels arent considered true canon but the IKS gorkon books deal withe the ship's first mission and begin with the captain commencing the battle record for the ship, saying he hopes it wil prove worthy.... anyway, my point is, the ship is already named.
As for use of IKS etc, even Feddies don't use the USS prefix all thetime. there are many occasions where we hear "the Enterprise is coming" and other ships are mentioned in conversations without their prefixes. On a formal occasion, however or one where its important to make it clear that this is a government approved ship on a legal mission, rather than a privateer or a private vessel (ie House fleet rather than Defence force) etc, a captain might use the IKS to emphasise that fact...? This might explain the inconsistant use of the prefix on screen.
As for the Vengeance, I love that quote.... and such a renowned captain and vessel need no further introduction...
Kehlan
Logged
Captain Kehlan
USS Endeavour NCC-71805
Federation/Klingon Rapid Response Fleet
Qunchuy
Discoursing Diplomat
Online
Posts: 279
Re: Multi Letter Abbreviations in Klingon Ship Names
«
Reply #4 on:
08 29, 2007, 06:34: AM »
Quote from: Klythe on 08 29, 2007, 01:09: AM
One thing I think is consistant. The only ones who use 'header' abbreviations are Starfleet officers. Klingons, so far as I've seen, only refer to their ships as "my (type-of-ship)" or by the name with nothing more than the word 'the' infront of the ship name. "the
pagh
", "the
bortaS
"
The very first Klingon ship named on screen was the IKC Amar, in the first few minutes of Star Trek: The Motion Picture. It was identified that way in the transmission from the ship's captain to the Klingon high command.
Logged
Abbot Nej vIt
Highly Opinionated Klingon
Thought Master
Offline
Posts: 790
"I Will Take the Conquerer Ceasers Salad... Now!"
Re: Multi Letter Abbreviations in Klingon Ship Names
«
Reply #5 on:
08 31, 2007, 07:18: PM »
I have had this discussion with others elswhere and in the past.
My opinion goes something like this:
- Klingons would be perhaps less likely to call their own vessel IKS ______ in conversation. But even the feddies to do not do so. Have we ever heard an away team member use their communicator to contact the ship by saying "Lt. Snuffy to the U.S.S. Enterprise-D"? No they would say "Lt. Snuffy to Enterprise." I think that the same could be said of Klingons from the perspective that qoSagh is coming from. In other words, even if Klingons did have ship ID prefixes they would not necessarily be used in general interaction.
- The usefulness of having ID prefixes comes into play when ships of different governments (Especially allies) come into contact with eachother. Much as country of registry flags do now with human sailing vessels. In this sense, Imperial Klingon Vessel, Imperial Klingon Ship or whatever could have a functional purpose. These might even be encoded into some sort of transponders or something making it unnecessary to actually say an ID prefix out loud.
- There could be different "Levels" of convention depending on the diplomatic situation at hand, which might call for the formal use of an ID prefix in certain situations but not others.
- The use of ID prefixes within fandom, particularly where an organized military unit is the model, can be a useful tool for identifying certain ship or perhaps Branch types, not to mention being able to tell a Klingon ship from a Star Fleet ship on a roster. How many IKV Marauders have I heard of over the years? Several. U.S.S. Marauders? Several... You get the idea.
So are ID prefixes a functional part of canon Klingon ship recognition/registry? Like so much on-screen in the Trek universe, we are left mostly with conjecture. I say yes there is evidence of canon use (As already mentioned)... But I think that Fandom has likely gone to more effort to assert regular conventions and procedures for how they are used.
maj! {Good}...
Logged
Archbishop Nej vIt SutaI-H'Nter,
Spiritual Advisor to K.L.A.W. 4th Fleet,
Abbot, Dugh toy'wI' Library,
http://www.klingonlegion.com/summergames2006/
Klythe
ngem Sargh lIghwI' pagh cha'
Administrator
Thought Master
Offline
Posts: 1019
When a show of teeth doesn't work, bite deeply.
Re: Multi Letter Abbreviations in Klingon Ship Names
«
Reply #6 on:
09 01, 2007, 01:17: AM »
More often though I reckon they are to distinguish classes of ship within an sovereignty... American Naval war ships use USS, civilian ships and Merchant Marine merely use SS...
Wikipedia says "Eight ships in the United States Navy have carried the name Enterprise. The prefix USS (for United States Ship) was not used until the late 1790s,[1] and until 1907 was only one of a number of prefixes used. Since 1907 the prefix has been used for all commissioned (and only for commissioned) ships of the U.S. Navy. In common usage, ship name prefixes are often applied retroactively to ships of the line that would have had said prefix under current practice."
Also there is a difference in registries... The original series USS Enterprise is NCC-1701 (Naval Construction Code)... Its predecessors NX-01 (Naval Experiment?) and
XCV-3230
also have seperate registry prefix. I don't remember if the NX-01 was prefixed with USS, I think it was... The other two were, in the case of the XCV 330, it stood for "United Space Ship"...
Since there are so many MLA prefixes for Klingon ships, I presume that all are valid usage. One would belong to the Imperial Navy, perhaps one also for the Imperial Marines, one for Privateers, civilian ships and privateers, perhaps also military ships operated by Houses... Yet another could be used for the KDF after the Imperial navy was re-organized...
Logged
Kragtowl
Novice
Offline
Posts: 11
"Never Trust a Smiling Klingon"
Re: Multi Letter Abbreviations in Klingon Ship Names
«
Reply #7 on:
02 04, 2010, 09:22: AM »
Quote from: qoSagh on 08 27, 2007, 08:02: AM
While reading another topic, there were many points brought up about Klingon ship names. This got me to thinking. For the most part, what we have to work with starts with I.K.V. for Imperial Klingon Vessel. This comes from FASA which developed it for the Role Playing Game, and I believe was used in other games also. Just a quick look at the ongoing debate on military ranks and one can see that for the ease of game mechanics much was done to make the Empire and the Federation more or less equal.
The only monkey wrench that I see is that I seem to remember somewhere (probably FASA) saying that Klingon ships are not named when they are launched, but named by their Captain after the ship has done something notable and earned the right to a name. So there might be an interaction with the Captain of an unnamed ship. In such cases, I would think just the rank and name of the Captain would be sufficient.
[Edit -- modified thread title for the benefit of spiderbots]
qoSagh!
I agree with you. When I founded the IKV Devastator in 1989, I used IKV (Imperial Klingon Vessel) as taken from the FASA Role-playing system. At that time it was the only guideline that I had to work with. FASA and if I remember right, the book "The Final Reflection" was where the naming of Klingon ships came from and it was called "naming of new steel". I truly do not think any variations is wrong, because with Klindom, we create our own, that is what separates us from Starfleet. Over the years, Klindom has established much of the culture and what is very funny, Paramount has included it in some of the episodes, LOL!
My compliments!
Logged
Qapla' balth je' (Honor and Success)
Kragtowl, Da'Har Master
Epetai of House Trekkan
Pages:
[
1
]
« previous
next »
Jump to:
Please select a destination:
-----------------------------
Forum Etiquette, News & Announcements
-----------------------------
=> Rules and Regulations: The Forum Etiquette & Posting Guidelines (MUST READ BEFORE POSTING)
=> Forum News & Announcements
===> Returning Members Must Read in Order to Sign In
=> Forum Feedback
-----------------------------
General Discussions
-----------------------------
=> The Reception Hall
=> General Discussions
=> Klingon News
===> Klingon Events & Activities
=====> Convention Reports and Reviews
=====> Invitations to Events (Open to All)
=====> Blood Drives
=====> Other
===> Klingon Community News
===> Klingons in the News
===> The Comics Section
-----------------------------
Klingon Language & Culture
-----------------------------
=> Klingon Ceremonies, Rituals & Traditions
===> Ceremonies & Traditions: General Questions & Discussion
===> Matters of Family, Line, and House
===> Klingon Religion and Spirituality
===> Warriors’ Rites & Traditions
=> Klingon Language
===> Requests for Translations
===> General Language Discussion in English
===> Conversation in thlIngan Hol only
=> Klingon Religion & Beliefs
=> Klingon Social Studies
-----------------------------
Klingon Arts and Media
-----------------------------
=> Klingon Arts and Music
===> Klingon Art and Artwork
===> Klingon Music and Lyrics
=> Klingon Poetry and Short Stories
===> Klingon Poetry
===> Klingon Short Stories
=> The Inspirational Media Room: Klingon-related Books, TV & Movies
===> Classics of Klingon Literature
===> Klingons on Television
===> Klingons on the Big Screen
-----------------------------
Other Klingon-related Topics
-----------------------------
=> The Klingon Kitchen
=> The Klingon Game Room
===> Klin Zha
===> RPGs and Sims
=====> Empire of Warriors RPG(Retired)
=====> Fall of the Hurq
=====> The Recruiting Center
===> Klingon and Star Trek computer games
=> The Klingon Science Lab
===> Klingon Biology & Physiology
===> Klingon Technology and Engineering
===> Stellar Sciences
=> The Klingon Marketplace
-----------------------------
Klingon Guilds
-----------------------------
=> Klingon Imperial Costumers Guild
===> Uniforms & Tunics
===> Pins, Jewelry & Badges
===> Props, Accessories & Footwear
===> Make-up & Headpieces
=> Klingon Webmasters Guild
===> Introduce Your Website
===> Web Design Questions
===> Software Reviews & Recommendations
===> Designing for Accessibility
=> Klingon Programmers Guild
=> Klingon Line Registry
===> Post your family line history
===> House and family alliances and adoptions
===> Places to promote your house, family, and line
===> General house & family line discussions